Friday, January 25, 2008

Smash Lab Sucks

It's a new show on Discovery. Comes on, lo and behold, after Mythbusters. The ads tell me that it's similar to Mythbusters, but apparently with more destruction (which while hard to fathom, ought to be true based on the title of the show. It looks like "Boom" but with some science.

I'm at minute 25 of an episode where they use this amazing material, carbon fiber (a cloth!) to make things stronger. Apparently jets are made out of it.

So, to test the strength of this stuff (it's cloth!) they take a 2x4 and cover it (staggeringly poorly) in carbon fiber. Then they test it against a control of another, un carbon fiber'd (cloth!) 2x4, by, get this, having all four of them stand on it.

Well good for them that it takes exactly all four of them to snap the wood, and they cannot manage to snap the carbon fiber'd 2x4.

That's to be expected, but all they've proven is it got stronger. they haven't shown why it's in fighter jets. They've shown that if you epoxy some carbon fiber over a 2x4 it can hold at least more than it could before.

Spreading raspberry jam on denim and wrapping a 2x4 would add that much strength. So would just epoxying the thing. So would fiberglass. So what's so special about the cloth???

How about you assholes get an inch more of a budget and go get some weights. Obviously you found that your 750 pounds busts a 2x4. Get some actual weights so you can see how much your poorly carbon fiber'd one can handle. The porn's in the numbers for this. If that reinforced 2x4 can hold five thousand pounds, that'd blow my damn mind. But i'll never know. Thanks guys!

Then they get to making a shack, for as far as I can tell, no other reason than to build it poorly and blow it apart with the backs of two airboats. Whoooo?

seriously, what was the point of that boring ass exercise other than showing me that the two people who built it aren't the best with tools.

So here we are, and they're dicking around with a mobile home to make it more hurricane resistant with carbon fiber. Maybe next week they can make it more hurricane resistant with bricks!

It's a dipshit show, and they're blowing the science end of it horribly, which I have to predict the path of the show based on this it'll be as such:

Mythbusters fans fall off pretty rapidly after posting on their blogs about the shitty science and how it's not Mythbusters. This leaves only the hillbilly jackoffs who wanna see things blow up, which should make this show last as long as "Boom" which was such a promising show, but damn if that didn't get boring after about two episodes.

Average viewership life: 1.6 episodes.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

I completely agree. This show is worthless. It looks like its done by a couple hacks that couldnt make it in college. In the last episode i saw they laid down a bed of air injected cement which is what they use at the airport to help stop aircraft. These geniuses expected it to do the same for a car traveling at 50+ mph. Then they had another team build a cement wall barrier with this stuff and it of course failed. I wonder why. A car has a lot more mass where it makes contact with this stuff then the small landing gear of a plan. It just blew my mind how they expected any of it to work.

Jack said...

they should have an auxilary show where people come on and tell them why their experiments are shitty.

Unknown said...

The show is a complete waste of electrons.

Jack said...

apparently it's still on. Might have to start Tivoing it to see if they got any more interesting or scientific about it.